This is a childhood classic for me. I’m super excited to get Mom’s Creamy Potato Soup on the blog!

4 simple ingredients, comfort food at it’s finest.

This is one of those dishes I just make – no recipe, I just make it. And every time I think about putting it here on this site I panic because writing a recipe is actually hard. You have to remember things and actually measure things.

This is a little different than other potato soups that I’ve had! There are no chunks of potatoes in it, it is smooth and creamy. I lived on this soup during my cancer treatments.

Mom’s Creamy Potato Soup

This is a super simple soup with 4 basic ingredients. I think the secret to this is boiling the potatoes with the onions.

AND AND AND I almost forgot! Make this with Fair Life milk and PROTEIN. Anything I can make with extra protein in a win in my book, like My Fair Mac and Cheese!

Salt is another key! Potatoes and salt have a complicated relationship – more complicated than Ross and Racheal on Friends even! So tasting this as you cook is important.

Too little salt makes the soup seem a little bland, too much and well, it’s salty. Just the right amount and the flavor of the soup really comes through.

This is a great make ahead recipe that can be kept warm in a crock pot! And can we just talk toppings for this soup – they are virtually unlimited!

Mom's Creamy Potato Soup

4 simple ingredients to make a creamy soup that you can top with anything you like!

Print Recipe Pin Recipe

Ingredients

5-6 medium sized potatoes peeled and diced
1 medium onion diced
1 teaspoon salt
water
1-2 cups milk
4 Tablespoons butter

Instructions

Peel and dice potatos; peel and dice onion
Put potatoes and onions in a medium sauce pan, add enough water to cover
Cook potatoes and onions on medium heat till potatoes are fall part tender
Drain potatoes and onions, reserve 1/2 cup of potato water
With an electric mixer mash potatoes, onions and reserved starch water
Once mashed put back in sauce pan and add butter and 1/2 cup of milk at a time until reached desired consistancy, heat on low heat until warm.
Add salt and pepper to taste - like literally taste soup and add salt and pepper till to your liking!